Maddow v Buchanan round 2

Last week I posted a link to a conversation between Rachel Maddown and Pat Buchanan on the Rachel Maddow Show. As I had hoped, tonight Rachel took the opportunity to correct the record on some of the racist 'facts' that Buchanan had offered. Go watch the clip! It's excellent.

In other news, some guy named Ralph Peters went out of his way to say that just on the off chance that Pfc. Bowe R. Burgdahl deserted his unit before being captured it would be better for him to be killed by the Taliban then return home safely. All indications at this time are that Burgdahl was captured by the enemy and is being forced to issue propaganda statements against his will. Way to support the troops, asshole.

Bill Moyers interviews Robert Wright

In an earlier post I talked about my visit to an atheist meetup group today. One of the things that was mentioned was this PBS interview with Robert Wright, author of The Evolution of God. Wright is a god-believer with a fairly enlightened point of view overall. The book mainly discusses how god belief and religion have evolved over time from stone age spirits that account for everyday events to bronze age pantheons that require animal sacrifices and on up to the modern day. He says in the interview that God is a 'construct' that has the traits that people have assigned to him.

It's when Wright starts talking about ethics that I have a real problem. He acknowledges that our moral sense and intuitions come from biological as well as cultural evolution. He uses game theory to show how in most situations ethics is not a zero-sum game, and cooperation can help everyone. I agree with these points. Wright goes on to say that our evolved moral senses are not perfect, which I also agree with. Then Wright delivers the surprise: belief in a personal god can help our moral development - we're better off with faith than without.

After all the good sense he was making before, I'm not sure why he chooses this moment to jump off the wagon. All of the great moral advancements of the past two centuries have been made not because of religion but over the loud objections of religion. The end of slavery, the expansions of voting rights, the civil rights movement all had prominent clergy quoting the bible trying to stand in the way of progress. Certainly some of the the people involved in these positive developments happened to be religious, but they often took their inspiration from outside their faith and brought the new understanding inside, reinterpreting the bible or other source of dogma through a new perspective.

ROBERT WRIGHT: One of my own closer contacts with, I would say, a form of consciousness that's closer to the truth than everyday consciousness, came at a Buddhist meditation center. These were essentially secular Buddhists and that was the context of the experience.

But through the meditative practice performed intensively for a week. No contact with the outside world. No speaking. Five and a half hours of sitting meditation a day. Five and a half hours of walking meditation a day. I reached a state of consciousness that I think is closer to the truth about things than the form of consciousness that is kind of natural for human beings.

BILL MOYERS: Was it a consciousness that had an ethical and moral issue in it or was it a state of being? A state of simple acceptance?

ROBERT WRIGHT: Well, it absolutely had ethical implications because it involved much broader acceptance of other beings and it involved being less judgmental of other beings. I mean it reached almost ridiculous extremes. Look looking down at weeds and thinking, "I can't believe I've been killing those things. They're actually as pretty as the grass. Prettier."

But in the realm of humanity, I mean I was just by the end being very much less judgmental about just people I would see on the street.
'Weeds' are what we make of them - they're any plant that the gardener is not interested in growing in a particular spot, a completely constructed idea. It took Wright ten hours of meditation a day to realize that some of them are pretty, and that you might at some point change your definition of what a weed is? It took him ten hours of meditation a day to be less judgmental to strangers?

I hardly see this as a great triumph of religious moral reasoning. If anything the environment Wright describes is the near lack of any culture whatsoever. Simply being absent from his judgmental patriarchial religious context for a short while allowed Wright to decompress a bit and refine his moral understanding. Did the Buddha do this? No, he did it himself. Kudos to Wright for the tentative advancements, but I'm not sure how he credits religion for this.

At the end of the clip I'm scratching my head and wondering why it came so highly recommended.

Today I attended an atheist meetup

My girlfriend and I went to an atheist meetup today. The Orlando Atheists and Freethinkers screened Julia Sweeney's Letting Go of God. Sweeney is a wonderful comedian and terribly fun to watch. She treats the subject of her deconversion with equal parts humor and sincerity. Unfortunately I had a tutoring appointment this afternoon and couldn't stay for the whole thing. It was difficult to walk out of the screening during the break in the middle.

Before the organizer put Sweeney's DVD on there was a bit of discussion. I've never been to a meeting of this group before but my girlfriend has once or twice. Before going there she had shared some of her impressions with me and today I was able to see for myself. My first disappointment was seeing immediately that almost all of the attendees (there were almost 30 people there) were over 40. In this country of course more young people are nonbelievers compared to the older generations. What accounts for this group's lack of youth appeal?

The organizer killed a wasp that landed on the projector screen. Someone said, "make sure to give it a Christian burial." Someone else said, "the trash!" In the context, the potshot against Christianity seemed to come out of nowhere. My girlfriend said, and I agree, that atheism should be bigger than to simply be against Christianity.

There was also a short discussion about spirituality. The organizer opened up by asking for anyone's definition of spirituality. A couple of answers were offered, some that didn't seem to mean anything at all and one which was the positive and connected feelings you get from the beauty in the natural world. Somebody else offered, "we have to acknowledge the slight possibility of something...".

I was confused. If spirituality is the feelings you get in contemplation of beauty, then we can do more than acknowledge a slight possibility. In fact I think that we can all agree that the feelings which are sometimes evoked by the beauty in the natural world can be inspiring, even life-changing. The comment seemed to imply that we should acknowledge the possibility of something more unusual or even supernatural. I don't feel like we need to go out of our way to acknowledge the slight possibility of something which up to this point has not been defined.

In any event, attending the meetup today was interesting and stimulating, particularly getting to see Julia Sweeney's show. It also helped my codify in my mind a little more what the current state of atheism is and what direction I would like to see it go. I don't mean to pick on the Orlando group particularly, especially since I've only seen a small slice of what they have to offer.

On the other hand, I've been thinking quite a bit about how the growing atheist movement needs a bit more development in terms of its identity, direction and goals. Expect more posts about this in the future.

I'm Reading: The Pluto Files by Neil deGrasse Tyson

Following the recent back-and-forth with PZ Myers and Mooney and Kirschenbaum prompted me to go read The Pluto Files by Neil deGrasse Tyson. It's been a couple of years now since Pluto was reclassified as a dwarf planet, so the controversy has died down a bit, but at the time a good number of people were fairly up in arms over it. This article from the New York Times featured prominently in the book. Looking back at the article from the present time, we can see that the Hayden Planetarium took a bold and prescient step by moving Pluto into the Kuiper Belt. In the book, Tyson recommends that we change the focus of solar system studies: instead of having students memorize the names of planets in order (you may have used mnemonics such as My Very Educated Mother Just Served Us Nine Pizzas) and then studying the properties of each planet, the solar system is more properly divided up into five families of objects that orbit the sun. The terrestrial planets lie between the sun and the asteroid belt. The jovian planets are large gaseous objects. Beyond them lie the small Kuiper belt objects (including Pluto) and the much more distant Oort cloud. Also not to be forgotten are the many varied and fascinating satellites, objects which orbit other bodies within the solar system.

The five families structure provides for a better and more interesting framework for studying the variety of the solar system. As a teacher, I will use this whenever the topic comes up. What is striking in Tyson's book is the strength of reaction among Pluto defenders. Some people apparently see questions like the number of planets as a stable, comforting foundation for their lives and any questions about Pluto's status as threatening or scary.

Mooney and Kirschenbaum apparently feel this way, with their repeated assertions that the Pluto controversy was handled poorly by scientists and science communicators. As a biologist, I do not understand the point of view that Pluto's change in status is frightening. Taxonomy is in the middle of a huge ongoing revolution as new molecular data enters the picture. A whole level of classifications - the domain level - has been added, and no branch of life has been immune to the shuffling. One of the things I've had to get used to as a biologist is the fact that old ideas in science must constantly make way for new information. Planetary astronomy has not had many upheavals lately, and people has gotten used to things sitting on a stable footing. It's a good thing for us to be flexible and open-minded in light of new information, not just as scientists but as citizens as well.

The Pluto Files (a book about plutophiles) is a fun and engaging read which I highly recommend. A short read, I was able to push through it in an afternoon.

Pat Buchanan in panic mode

http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/26315908/#31952924

Video is 16 minutes long, Buchanan comes in around 4:30.

If you've ever wondered what it looks like when a racist is afraid that the 200+ year history of white male dominance in this country is over, check this out. In this fascinating interview, Rachel Maddow keeps her cool while Pat Buchanan rants and foams at the mouth.

Buchanan: I don't think Judge Sotomayor is qualified for the United States Supreme Court. She has not shown any great intellect here or any great depth of knowledge of the Constitution. She's never written anything that I've read in terms of a law review article or a major book or something like that on the law. And I do believe that she's an affirmative action appointment by the President.


Apparently the fact that Sotomayor has more experience on the bench than any currently sitting SCOTUS judge had at their confirmation does not count for much, nor does the fact that she was very rarely overturned during her career by higher courts. Buchanan apparently believes the purpose of affirmative action is to discriminate against white males. He feels that the fact that historically 108 of 110 supreme justices are white males simply reflects the inherently superior abilities of white males.

Buchanan: ...white men were 100% of the people who wrote the Constitution, 100% of the people who signed the Declaration of Independence, 100% of the people who died at Gettysburg and Vicksburg, probably close to 100% of the people who died at Normandy.


His racism blinds him to the contributions of other groups. Where I see a history of disenfranchisement and unfairness he sees the natural order of things. Buchanan unfairly dismisses all of Sotomayor's qualifications as the product of affirmative action. Maddow asks if Buchanan sees the nomination of a latina to the SCOTUS as a positive thing for this country and he dodges the question.

Firefighters whine, ask for empathy

I just watched the testimony of two of the firefighters who were plaintiffs in the Ricci case speak their piece at the Sotomayor hearings. When Sotomayor's appeals court summarily dismissed the case, they acted according to existing law which specified that if a policy was discriminatory in practice then it is illegal. The Supreme Court overturned this law as written. What was striking to me while listening to these firefighters was how their arguments centered over two things:

1) We studied really hard for this test.

2) Our feelings were hurt when our case was dismissed.

Here we have, on one hand, a judge dispassionately applying the law as written, and a group of plaintiffs (who have been given a platform to speak by Republican senators) asking for empathy!

Kudos to Hindus!

Recently Pope "Hitler Youth" Benedict blasted atheism and humanism, writing, "...ideological rejection of God and an atheism of indifference, oblivious to the Creator and at risk of becoming equally oblivious to human values, constitute some of the chief obstacles to development today. A humanism which excludes God is an inhuman humanism." As inhuman as the crusades or the inquisition? As inhuman as shielding child molesters from criticism and prosecution? As inhuman as systematically abusing children, not just sexually but physically and emotionally as well?

So thanks and congrats to Rajan Zed for standing up for religious tolerance and inclusion. In recognition of Zed's words, I'd like to say some nice things about Hinduism as well. I admit to some ignorance here; I'll be checking Wikipedia for my facts. Hinduism is the world's oldest and most diverse religion, and the third-largest today. It's staggering diversity makes it somewhat hard to say what it is and is not, but a few recurring themes stand out. Hindus believe in karma, a universal force that rewards goodness and punishes evil. Contrast this with othe well-known religions which reward faith and obedience as opposed to doing the right thing. Hinduism incorporates the concept of creative destruction, where the universe is constantly being destroyed and created, that these processes are two sides of the same coin. This seems neither good nor bad from a moral perspective, but might be seen as a somewhat accurate description of the world as revealed by science: our planet is constructed out of the debris of previous stars that went supernova.

Like all human societies, Indian culture has its injustices. But unlike in the West these injustices rarely happen as a policy of religious dogma. What's more, the polytheistic nature of Hinduism and the diversity it contains tends to create an attitude of openness and inclusion towards other religions. The situ Iation with Pakistan and Kashmir seems to be the glaring exception. I tend to be somewhat more inclined to assign blame to the Muslims in this case, but knowing as little as I do I may be wrong about this. Every Pakistani I have met has been intelligent, open, and engaging. I understand that Pakistan has a strong tradition of positive civil institutions and respect for democracy, despite their recent trouble.

To sum up: Hinduism is a great religion which I have nothing but respect for. Thanks and kudos particularly to Rajan Zed and his like-minded compatriots. Boos and hisses to Pope Benedict and Bill Donohue. Those two should take their heads out of their asses and realize it's not the middle ages any more and people are allowed to follow the religion of their choosing, including none at all.